Mordechai Twersky, a former communal leader from the Bronx who once
ran for the New York State Assembly, now lives in Israel. It’s a sure
bet, however, that he will vote by absentee ballot in the New York
Republican Presidential primary next year. Mr. Twersky is the founder of
Giuliani Supporters in Israel, a grass-roots effort to mobilize support
for the former NYC mayor from Israelis with US citizenship.
If Mr. Twersky, 43, has his way, every Israeli citizen or resident
with the right to vote in the US, will "get off the TV sofa and use the
means at his or her disposal to ensure that the next President of the US
will not only support Israel, but will have a strong enough character
and personality to express that support in unequivocal terms."
"As far as I am concerned, there is only one candidate who meets this
criterion: Rudolph W. Giuliani," said Mr. Twersky.
Thousands of Voters
There are thousands of eligible voters in Israel. No one doubts that,
in a close election, every absentee ballot could count.
The Republicans and Democrats Abroad organizations have been active
in Israel for many years, but Mr. Twersky said his was the first
campaign that has ever been established in Israel to help a candidate
win a party primary.
He has set up a website at giulianisupportsinisrael.org and plans to
hold regular parlor meetings to convince as many eligible voters as
possible that Mr. Giuliani is the best qualified candidate to meet the
threats facing the United States, Israel, and the rest of the Free
World.
The Standard
"Rudolph Giuliani has set the standard for leadership," said Mr.
Twersky, ticking off such issues as crime, terrorism, and friendship
with the Jewish community and the State of Israel.
"He has backed up his statements with concrete action. Who can forget
his reaction to the Crown Heights riots and the murder of Yankel
Rosenbaum in 1991? Or how he evicted Yasir Arafat from a concert at
Lincoln Center in 1995?" said Mr. Twersky.
He noted that, as mayor of New York, Mr. Giuliani rushed to Israel to
show solidarity with the Jewish state during some of the most brutal
Palestinian terror attacks. When Saudi Prince Alwaleed bin Talal, in the
aftermath of the September 11 attacks, offered Mr. Giuliani a check for
$10 million in relief aid along with the suggestion that the US
"re-examine its policies in the Middle East and adopt a more balanced
stand toward the Palestinian cause," Mr. Giuliani promptly—and very
publicly—tore up the check.
Mr. Giuliani is now calling on the US to create a viable military
option against Iran in order to make American economic sanctions
stronger.
"For all these and reasons and more, I believe Giuliani is best
suited to lead the US in the battle against the threats facing it and
its lone Middle East ally, Israel," said Mr. Twersky. "Giuliani is a
leader. He is a role model, the perfect example of a man who dared to
fight crime—and won. He was there—literally—when the World Trade Center
fell. He took to his heart the terrorists’ blow to the strength and
security of America. With his own unique blend of stubbornness,
sensitivity, and zero-tolerance, he truly understands the need and the
obligation for a determined, unremitting fight against terrorism. Mr.
Giuliani is the perfect example of a true leader, with executive
capabilities and vast experience in coping with the kind of pressure and
crises which overcome even the best of us."
Helping Israel
Mr. Twersky said that when he immigrated to Israel in 1998, he
believed he would be able to focus solely on democratic life in the
Jewish state. He even ran unsuccessfully for the Knesset in the last
election.
Now, however, prompted by the Iranian nuclear threat, increasing
Palestinian terrorism, the rumbles of warfare once again from Hezbollah
in Lebanon, and corruption in Israel’s political system, he no longer
believes Israel can cope on its own with the political and security
risks.
"The manifestations of corruption which shock Israeli citizens from
one day to the next, along with the course of last summer’s war in
Lebanon, have undermined my confidence. I now realize that—precisely as
an American citizen—I have a role to play in ensuring that Israel has an
external ‘anchor.’ As Iran builds its nuclear program, as the
Palestinian Authority and Hezbollah prepare for military conflict with
Israel, we will need a friend in the White House who will bring clarity
and consistency to US foreign policy while safeguarding the American
Homeland and preserving the safety and security of its lone Middle East
ally," he said.
Social Issues
He did not deny that some of Mr. Giuliani’s positions on domestic
social issues, particularly abortion and homosexuality, are at odds with
the beliefs of most religious conservatives, including Mr. Twersky
himself, who is a member of the Orthodox community. But, he said, those
issues pale in comparison to the existential threat faced by the Free
World.
"My top priority is to deal with threats to our
existence—international terrorism and the Iranian nuclear threat," he
said, pointing out that, according to a recent poll, nearly half of the
Israeli public fears that Israel may not exist in 2048.
"So with all due deference to social issues, I prefer to concentrate
on our existence," said Mr. Twersky.
Survivor Family
He comes by those fears honestly. His parents, the late Rabbi Yaakov
Yosef Twersky of the Bronx Park East Chotiner Jewish Center on Pelham
Parkway, and his mother, Pearl Twersky, were Holocaust survivors who
became deeply involved in the Bronx Jewish community.
"As the scion of a rabbinic family and son of Holocaust survivors, I
am deeply worried about the future existence of Israel. As I see it, the
struggle against terrorism and the Iranian nuclear threat have profound
implications for global stability, the safety of the American homeland,
and the safety of Israel. When these threats against Israel and the US
are so pronounced, one must not sit idly by, but should be propelled to
action," he said.
Mr. Twersky said he founded Giuliani Supporters in Israel first to
mobilize support for Mr. Giuliani from American voters living, working,
or studying in Israel and second to strengthen Mr. Giuliani’s popularity
among Israelis.
"American Jews value Israeli public opinion," he said.
Mr. Twersky said the response to his campaign and the website have
been "overwhelmingly positive."
"People want to get involved on behalf of Giuliani Supporters in
Israel. They realize what’s at stake. Clearly, we’ve tapped into their
concerns," he said.
Olmert’s Friend
The counsel in Israel for Democrats Abroad, Sheldon Schorer, did not
think Mr. Giuliani was any more pro-Israel than the Democratic front
runners, New York Senator Hillary Clinton and Illinois Senator Barack
Obama. "I am sure the voters will see that as well," said Mr. Schorer.
One problem Mr. Giuliani may have in Israel is his close friendship
with beleaguered Prime Minister Ehud Olmert. As mayors of New York and
Jerusalem, respectively, Messrs Giuliani and Olmert forged a close
personal and political alliance. In recent media interviews, Mr. Olmert
has hinted broadly that he is supporting Mr. Giuliani.
Mr. Schorer called Mr. Olmert’s hints "highly inappropriate," and Mr.
Twersky called the prime minister "extremely irresponsible."
"It is highly appropriate for Americans in Israel to be involved in
American politics, but it is highly inappropriate for the Israeli
government to express a preference for one personality or another who
could lead the American people. It’s their job to work with whoever
Americans choose to lead America," said Mr. Schorer.
Mr. Twersky said he did not think Mr. Olmert’s support or lack
thereof would influence the Israeli public’s perception of Mr. Giuliani.
"What counts in the minds of Israelis is Giuliani’s leadership after
9-11 and his unwavering support for Israel," he said.
Pro-Israel Democrats?
Mr. Twersky, however, took issue with Mr. Schorer’s assessment of the
Democratic front runners’ support for Israel. "Please, don’t make me
laugh," he said, recalling that, in 1998, "before Hillary became a
staunchly pro-Israel senator from New York," she expressed support for
Yasir Arafat’s threatened unilateral declaration of Palestinian
statehood.
In November 1999, at the dedication of a US-funded health program in
Gaza, Mrs. Clinton exchanged kisses with Mr. Arafat’s wife, Suha, right
after the Palestinian First Lady delivered a speech in Arabic claiming
that Israel had deliberately subjected Palestinians to "poisonous gas."
Although Mrs. Clinton had been wearing headphones to receive a
simultaneous translation of Mrs. Arafat’s inflammatory speech, Mrs.
Clinton did not apologize for her embrace of Mrs. Arafat until almost 24
hours later. Some of her supporters said she did not receive an accurate
translation of the speech until much later; others said she had not been
paying attention.
During her Senate campaign, Mrs. Clinton said the kiss was just a
"formality" akin to a handshake. She said that had she not kissed Mrs.
Arafat, it would have caused a diplomatic incident. However, Mrs.
Clinton said, she believed going to the event altogether had been a
mistake.
Obama
Asked about Mr. Obama, Mr. Twersky said the Illinois Senator had "no
proven record regarding Israel." "His statements are in the context of a
Presidential election and part of an effort to curry favor among Jewish
voters," said Mr. Twersky.
During the recent Democratic candidates’ debate, Mr. Obama was asked
to name America’s "three most important allies around the world." When
he named the European Union, Afghanistan, and Japan, the moderator noted
that he had omitted Israel and asked the candidate to explain his quote
that "no one is suffering more than the Palestinian people."
Mr. Obama said what he meant is that "nobody has suffered more than
the Palestinian people from the failure of the Palestinian leadership to
recognize Israel, renounce violence, and get serious about negotiating
peace and security for the region." Mr. Obama then said that "Israel has
been one of our most important allies around the world."
Front Runner
Most polls show Mr. Giuliani is still the front runner among
Republican candidates. Polls also show him running ahead of virtually
all potential Democratic candidates as well. He has a 62 percent
favorability rating, and 49 percent of all voters categorize him as
"politically moderate" rather than "right wing."
After the California debate among all announced Republican
candidates, a SurveyUSA poll found that 30 percent of those in
California who watched the debate decided Mr. Giuliani was "the winner."
The second and third places went to former Massachusetts Governor Mitt
Romney (12 percent) and Arizona Senator John McCain (11 percent).
According to a Quinnipiac Poll, Mr. Giuliani would beat Mrs. Clinton
49-40 percent and Mr. Obama 44 to 41 percent.
In New Jersey, a Strategic Vision poll showed Mr. Giuliani in the
lead among his Republican opponents. When 800 likely Republican voters
were asked whom they would support for the Republican nomination in
2008, 49 percent said Mr. Giuliani. Mr. McCain received 15 percent, and
everyone else was in the single digits.